Refine Search
Sort by
$346,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 2988197 MLS CLOSED Status 1.3 Acres 37356 Zip Code
This turn-key getaway is just minutes from Main Street in Monteagle or hiking the Fiery Gizard Trail! The home has been completely renovated and features a massive living area with vaulted pine ceilings and a cozy fireplace. It's truly the perfect place to snuggle up for a movie or family game night. The kitchen is open to the living room and has tons of counter space for cooking and entertaining. Whether you're seeking a weekend retreat, an investment opportunity, or a beautiful family home, this property delivers. Perhaps the best feature of this home is the large covered front porch that is perfect for enjoying the summer breeze or watching the snow fall in the winter. Sitting on just over an acre, this property has a firepit area that's perfect for gathering around bonfires and roasting s'mores. Deer often wander by, making it feel like your own little retreat. The property has been a successful air bnb for the last 4 years. Seller would prefer to sell furnished!

10853 US 41, Monteagle

$340,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 3169495 MLS CLOSED Status 1.8 Acres 37356 Zip Code
The home is set back from the road and this property has so many options for you! Plenty of sunny space for a garden and a huge workshop for all your projects! Home has an open floor place and a beautiful stone fireplace in the living room and tons of built in storage plus bookcases surround it. Large walk in pantry is just off the kitchen with a build in hutch and shelving, oversize laundry room and a mud room just off the double garage. Main bedroom has a big walk in closet and bath attached. There are 3 bedrooms and two baths plus front porch and a big rear deck. Home faces the side so you can enjoy your porch and deck looking into the woods. The workshop/barn has water and electricity plus separate storage areas for gardening and workshop things plus there is a large loft area as well. It also has another double garage attached to it, you have space for 4 plus cars and trucks to be covered and enclosed. There is also a small storage building on the property in the rear of the home.

251 Wells St, Monteagle

$292,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 2996787 MLS CLOSED Status 0.4 Acres 37356 Zip Code
MOTIVATED SELLER! Move-In-By-Christmas Package: Get a FREE Christmas.COMPETIVELY PRICED!! FREE 1-year home warranty.Welcome to this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home that perfectly blends modern updates with natural beauty. Step inside to find granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a spacious pantry in the kitchen. The open dining area features a large glass sliding door leading to the stunning modern black covered deck—the perfect spot to relax while overlooking your private, wooded backyard. The home is filled with natural light! The primary suite offers a peaceful retreat, while the thoughtful layout provides comfort and function for everyday living. Enjoy the outdoors with plenty of shade and a backyard that feels like your own nature escape. But check out the comps -- Homes of a similar size and geographic area have sold recently for an AVERAGE of $226 per square foot -- new construction and renovated homes between $250-$290 per square foot. This little gem is priced at $204 per square foot! Seller is building a brand new construction home right in front of this house, plus three additional new construction homes to the right of the house, which will only add value and equity to this home!! Full of possibilities and set in one of the most desirable areas on the mountain, this home is a true gem at a great price! Enjoy the charm of small-town living with quick access to Hwy 41 and I-24 for an easy commute. Just minutes from local favorites like Mountain Goat Market, the historic High Point restaurant, and the distinctive shops and dining in Monteagle and Sewanee. Outdoor lovers will appreciate being close to state parks, waterfalls, hiking trails, and endless recreation. Whether you’re searching for a primary residence, weekend getaway, or investment opportunity, this property delivers both value and location. Don’t miss your chance! Special Financing Available! Buyer receives a 1% lender credit applied to lower the interest rate with the preferred lender.

405 Spring St, Monteagle

$275,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 2976292 MLS CLOSED Status 0.36 Acres 37356 Zip Code
Welcome to easy & convenient modern living here in the heart of downtown Monteagle, TN! This newly built duplex unit, features two attached home units. Both feature 2 bed, 2 bath, 1 car garage. Great investment property that seamlessly blends functional modern convivence, low maintaince, w/ stylish comfort. The front entry welcomes you and leads to open concept kitchen and living space, with a large sliding doors allowing lots of natural light and access into the back deck. The kitchen boasts granite countertops, providing elegance & durability, complemented by brand-new stainless steel appliances & pop up charging port on the large eat in island. The primary suite is a standout feature, complete with a spacious walk in closet, luxury granite vanity & tiled walk in shower in the large bathroom suite. The one car garage adds an extra layer of convenience for residents, ensuring secure parking & additional storage space. Each duplex is 1290 sqft not including the garage. Enjoy the luxury of a hassle-free lifestyle w/ low maintenance in this newly constructed townhome. This property has never been rented or lived in. Option to purchase both units individually see listing on MLS #2943531

501 Lautzenheiser Pl, Monteagle

$264,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 3215240 MLS CLOSED Status 1 Acres 37356 Zip Code
Step inside this beautifully renovated 4-bedroom, 2-bath home located within Monteagle city limits. The kitchen is a standout, featuring new cabinets, granite countertops, and stainless-steel appliances, perfect for cooking and entertaining. This home also offers a brand-new HVAC system with updated ductwork, a storage building, and plenty of additional features designed for convenience and comfort. The partially fenced backyard with chain link provides extra security for children and pets. Located close to local amenities and the interstate, this home combines modern upgrades with a functional layout and move-in-ready appeal. Home is within a short distance of the Mountain Goat walking trail that currently runs from Sewanee to Tracy City and the South Cumberland State Park, where families can hike, play different types of ball, picnic and more. Seller is owner/agent.

362 Forrest Point Rd, Monteagle

$250,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 3183461 MLS CLOSED Status 1.88 Acres 37356 Zip Code
Well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2 bath home situated on approximately 1.88 acres and conveniently located just minutes from I-24! This home offers an open-concept living and kitchen area with durable LVP flooring, perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The spacious primary suite features a double vanity, soaking tub, separate shower, and walk-in closet. Recent updates include a new 55-gallon water heater (2023), along with newer stove and dishwasher. Outside, you’ll find a 12x20 shed (2021), concrete work completed in 2020, and additional features such as a chicken coop and house ideal for those looking for a little extra space and functionality. Property is on a permanent foundation and includes a septic system. Energy-efficient improvements have been added, enhancing overall comfort and value. Enjoy the peaceful setting with the convenience of being close to interstate access, making commuting a breeze.

720 Trussell Rd, Monteagle

$240,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 3242477 MLS CLOSED Status 0.75 Acres 37356 Zip Code
Welcome to 374 N Bluff Circle in Monteagle! Situated on approximately 0.75 acres, this beautifully remodeled 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers around 1,300 square feet of updated, move-in-ready living space. Thoughtfully remodeled throughout, the home features a beautifully updated master with a tiled shower, along with a convenient Jack-and-Jill bathroom connecting the additional two bedrooms. The fresh interior offers a comfortable and inviting layout ready for its next owner. Step outside and enjoy the mountain setting, complete with a creek located along the back of the property perfect for relaxing and enjoying the sounds of nature. An existing poured concrete pad also provides potential for a future garage, workshop, carport, or additional outdoor space, subject to applicable approvals. Conveniently located near Monteagle amenities, shopping, dining, outdoor recreation, and easy access to I-24, this property offers updated living while maintaining the quiet charm of mountain life. Whether you’re searching for a primary residence, weekend retreat, or investment opportunity, this fully remodeled home offers comfort, convenience, natural beauty, and plenty of future potential. Schedule your showing today!

374 N Bluff Cir, Monteagle

$234,500
1 Beds 1 Baths 3215195 MLS CLOSED Status 1.05 Acres 37356 Zip Code
Stunning Tiny Home in a gated community that sleeps 6!! This adorable cottage style home sits on a boastful 1.05acre lot that leads to a tire swing, firepit, and walking trails!! The home features Quartz countertops, oversized windows for plenty of natural sunlight, and French double doors that lead to the large deck that is perfect for enjoying the serine environment!! Whether you want this to be your forever home or just a weekend getaway this property provides peace and quiet, park like amenities, and simple living at it's finest!! This property backs up to walking trails that lead to beautiful waterfalls!! Fiber Internet is available, tankless hot water heater for endless supply of hot water, & a turnkey investment property!! All items in the home at the time of showing do convey with the property!!

314 Deer Lick Trl, Monteagle

$229,900
2 Beds 2 Baths 3128890 MLS CLOSED Status 0.96 Acres 37356 Zip Code
SELLER IS OFFERING $5,000 TOWARDS BUYER'S CLOSING COSTS. Home is back on market at no fault to the sellers! The buyers financing fell through. Welcome to this thoughtfully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath home set on a peaceful 1-acre lot in the heart of Monteagle. Inside, you’ll find an inviting open-concept layout where the kitchen and living area blend seamlessly—ideal for entertaining guests or enjoying quiet evenings at home. The kitchen offers modern finishes, generous counter space, and a bright, airy feel that carries throughout the living space. Start your mornings on the covered front porch and wind down in the evenings on the spacious back porch overlooking your private yard. With tasteful updates throughout, this home perfectly balances modern comfort with the charm and serenity of small-town living. Conveniently located just minutes from local shops, dining, and the natural beauty of the Cumberland Plateau, you’ll enjoy both accessibility and tranquillity. • Special financing available – Buyer receives a 1% lender credit to help lower the interest rate with the preferred lender • FREE 1-year home warranty included Move-in ready and full of charm—schedule your showing today! (Some furniture items can be negotiable)

103 Highland Dr, Monteagle

$208,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 3176556 MLS CLOSED Status 0.34 Acres 37356 Zip Code
Completely renovated in 2023, this charming and bright 1-story contemporary home delivers style, comfort, and ultimate flexibility. Featuring 2 bedrooms plus a versatile flex room (ideal for a home office, hobby room, or guest space) and 2 full bathrooms. Enjoy modern finishes throughout, including a spacious primary suite with a true walk-in-closet and en suite bath, plus a bright, open living layout. Major peace of mind comes with a brand-new septic tank (chamber system), water heater, and HVAC all recently added. Situated on a peaceful, private 0.34-acre wooded lot with a covered porch, deck, and a large gravel driveway accommodating up to 4 vehicles. Just minutes from Sewanee, I-24, hiking trails, and local dining. Refrigerator, washer, and dryer remain! Suitable for starter home, down-sizing, or lucrative Air BnB

629 Nickajack Trl, Monteagle

$195,000
1 Beds 1 Baths 3009655 MLS CLOSED Status 0.34 Acres 37356 Zip Code
If you’ve been searching for a place to slow down, breathe in fresh mountain air, and escape the noise, welcome to your retreat. Tucked inside the gated community of The Retreat at Deer Lick Falls, this thoughtfully crafted tiny home blends cozy comfort with outdoor living you’ll want to enjoy year-round. Start your mornings on the expansive 500 sq. ft. deck, coffee in hand, as sunlight filters through the trees. Spend your afternoons exploring community walking trails, discovering the waterfall, or relaxing in the private hot tub while the world slips away. Inside, quartz countertops give the kitchen a polished, modern feel, and the open living area—with its inviting fireplace—sets the tone for quiet evenings or gatherings with friends. A loft offers additional sleeping space, making room for both family and guests. Currently offered as “Bungalow by the Falls” on Airbnb, this property comes fully turnkey—ready to continue as a thriving short-term rental or become your own private getaway. Whether you envision unwinding in the hot tub, hosting friends on the spacious deck, or exploring the community’s trails and waterfall, it’s all right outside your door in this peaceful Tennessee setting.

574 Deer Lick Trl, Monteagle

$167,500
4 Beds 2 Baths 3181145 MLS CLOSED Status 0.67 Acres 37356 Zip Code
Welcome to this quaint Monteagle prime location with green fields and mature trees. Motivated seller due to relocation in pursuit of his dream job in Alabama. This is a wonderful tranquil neighborhood. This beautiful home is a work in progress that has tremendous potential and offers alot! Much has been done but now the seller is motivated to sell due to employment opportunity and the need to relocate. This is a wonderful and tranquil neighborhood. The rooms are…. The rooms are very large to scale compared to today's general builds. Spacious bedrooms, huge kitchen and living room areas. Two fireplaces, one gas and one electric. Three car garage (29.8x25.7). Huge sun porch on the back(36.2x11.8). Enjoy the beauty looking out over the peaceful backyard and open field behind the property. Property offers a cute detailed wooden fence around the front and sides. Many fruit trees, beautiful flowers and a spacious back yard. An extra bonus is a nice storage shed out back. This must see property is very unique in what it offers, especially at this price point. Buyer and or Buyers rep to verify all information. Washer, Dryer and Refrigerator do not convey. This is truly a wonderful location to live and the area offers so much to take in and enjoy. The University of the South (Sewanee), Cumberland State Park, Fiery Gizzard Trail, Foster Falls and Savage Gulf. Experience mountain living at its finest with lakes and streams. Take in the music at the Caverns in (Pelham). The Seller is Motivated, and the home is being sold As Is. There are a few areas that need refurbished and completed. The Bruce hard wood flooring and tile along with the glass door to finish the projects conveys. This property is a Must See; feel the charm, beauty and total peace.

392 Hardbarger Rd, Monteagle

$120,000
3179256 MLS CLOSED Status 11.07 Acres 37356 Zip Code
Just over 11 acres that offer total seclusion and modern convenience on a dead-end street in the beautiful gated community of Timberwood Trace. These two lots are being sold together, are ready to build with utilities at the road, drive cut in on both lots, partial build site cleared, perced, surveyed and ready for your new home. Seller (licensed general contractor) will build to suite if desired. Lot 325 has 108ft of bluff frontage. Lot 326 has a bluff view through the trees. The lots feature mature hardwoods with cleared underbrush and lush greenery that provide a natural buffer from the outside world. Timberwood Trace offers both privacy, security and convenience—just minutes from the University of the South in charming Sewanee, downtown Monteagle, and the Mountain Goat Trail. Outdoor lovers will appreciate being a short drive from Tracy City and South Cumberland State Park, where stunning waterfalls and hiking trails await.

Timberwood Trace Lot 325 & 326, Monteagle

$68,000
3163556 MLS CLOSED Status 7 Acres 37356 Zip Code
Escape to the Trees: Your Private Sanctuary at Timberwood Trace Discover the perfect canvas for your architectural masterpiece on Lot 340. Nestled deep within the prestigious gated community of Timberwood Trace, this expansive 7-acre wooded property offers the rare combination of total seclusion and modern convenience. If you’ve been searching for a place where the only neighbors you’ll see are the local wildlife, this is it. Total Privacy: Seven acres of mature hardwoods and lush greenery provide a natural buffer from the outside world. Build-Ready: Utilities are already at the road, significantly streamlining your development process. Exclusive Location: Situated inside a secure, gated community known for its tranquil atmosphere. You’ll enjoy the peace of mind that comes with a gated entrance and well-maintained community standards, all while feeling miles away from the hustle and bustle. Bring your builder, bring your blueprints, and start living the life you’ve imagined among the trees.

1188 Timberwood Trce, Monteagle

$65,000
3051531 MLS CLOSED Status 37356 Zip Code
Come build on the Mountain! Just under an acre in one of the most desirable communities in Monteagle. A nice lot with minimum slope; Water meter is in place. Home site is cleared and ready for new construction. Owner intended to build a two bedroom home and applied for septic permit to support that structure. However, the land will likely accommodate a larger size home. Electric and FIBER are located in front of the lot at Laurel Lake Dr. No HOA fees! The lot is about 5 min off I-24, very close to Sewanee, The University of the South, climbing, hiking, waterfalls, golfing, The Caverns, Big Foot Adventures, etc. There is so much to do and enjoy on the mountain! Build your forever home or a retreat. Perfect location for an AirBNB!!!

Laurel Lake Dr, Monteagle

$60,000
3154977 MLS CLOSED Status 0.459 Acres 37356 Zip Code
This commercial lot is located less than ½ mile from Exit 134 on I-24 in a rapidly growing commercial corridor. The property has access to city water, sewer, and power at the road, making it ready for development. Within one mile of the property are numerous successful businesses, including Pizza Hut, Dollar General, Mountain Outfitters, CS Automotive, Jim Oliver's Smoke House, Circle K, Piggly Wiggly, Subway, Hardee's, Super 8, Waffle House, Sonic Drive-In, and McDonald's, among others—demonstrating the strong commercial presence in the immediate area. Just down the road are two upscale residential communities, Cliff Tops and Cooley’s Rift, and the property is less than a 10-minute drive to The University of the South in Sewanee. What makes this property truly unique is its special use exemption that allows for multifamily residential development. Whether you are looking for an excellent site for a commercial venture or planning to build residential apartments, this property offers exceptional potential. Don’t miss this opportunity at auction!

W Main St, Monteagle

$60,000
3154980 MLS CLOSED Status 0.459 Acres 37356 Zip Code
This commercial lot is located less than ½ mile from Exit 134 on I-24 in a rapidly growing commercial corridor. The property has access to city water, sewer, and power at the road, making it ready for development. Within one mile of the property are numerous successful businesses, including Pizza Hut, Dollar General, Mountain Outfitters, CS Automotive, Jim Oliver's Smoke House, Circle K, Piggly Wiggly, Subway, Hardee's, Super 8, Waffle House, Sonic Drive-In, and McDonald's, among others—demonstrating the strong commercial presence in the immediate area. Just down the road are two upscale residential communities, Cliff Tops and Cooley’s Rift, and the property is less than a 10-minute drive to The University of the South in Sewanee. What makes this property truly unique is its special use exemption that allows for multifamily residential development. Whether you are looking for an excellent site for a commercial venture or planning to build residential apartments, this property offers exceptional potential. Don’t miss this opportunity at auction!

W Main St, Monteagle

$60,000
3154970 MLS CLOSED Status 0.459 Acres 37356 Zip Code
This commercial lot is located less than ½ mile from Exit 134 on I-24 in a rapidly growing commercial corridor. The property has access to city water, sewer, and power at the road, making it ready for development. Within one mile of the property are numerous successful businesses, including Pizza Hut, Dollar General, Mountain Outfitters, CS Automotive, Jim Oliver's Smoke House, Circle K, Piggly Wiggly, Subway, Hardee's, Super 8, Waffle House, Sonic Drive-In, and McDonald's, among others—demonstrating the strong commercial presence in the immediate area. Just down the road are two upscale residential communities, Cliff Tops and Cooley’s Rift, and the property is less than a 10-minute drive to The University of the South in Sewanee. What makes this property truly unique is its special use exemption that allows for multifamily residential development. Whether you are looking for an excellent site for a commercial venture or planning to build residential apartments, this property offers exceptional potential. Don’t miss this opportunity at auction!

W Main St, Monteagle

board logo

Information Is Believed To Be Accurate But Not Guaranteed. Some or all listings may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting these featured properties. Copyright 2026 MTRMLS, Inc. RealTracs Solutions.